T1B

I'm watching the Cards at Cubs and Derrick Lee hits an apparent foul ball that the 3rd base umpire rules a homerun. Larussa comes out to ask for another opinion, and the home plate umpire overrules the original call.

When I first saw it, it looked way foul. During slow mo replay, it was clear it stayed just inside the pole, right above that screen that sticks out.

Joe Morgan is saying that if it were fair, it would have dis-appeared behind the foul pole during the replay. Guess what Joe. It did, on both replays that were shown.

I've got $20 that says ESPN never shows that replay again.

it was foul you retard



the ball crossed in front of foul pole, and ended up 3 feet foul!

No, it wasn't foul. The ball clearly hooked inside, and around, the pole.

Speaking of retards, how did I just know that you'd be the first to respond?

War Wagon wrote:No, it wasn't foul. The ball clearly hooked inside, and around, the pole.

Speaking of retards, how did I just know that you'd be the first to respond?

it hooked in front of the pole.


Don't you get tired of an idiot?? Noone but your dumbass, thinks the ball is fair after the replay!


and to insinuate that espn wouldnt replay the Call in question proves how big of a tard you are.

Adelpiero wrote: Don't you get tired of an idiot??

What and lose my favorite St. Loser punching bag?

No, you can stay.

War Wagon wrote:

Adelpiero wrote: Don't you get tired of an idiot??

What and lose my favorite St. Loser punching bag?

No, you can stay.

grammar smack, tarding up MLB and NHL forums, being piled on.

Typical day for tardling Wags!



congrats

That's not grammar smack, son. That's coherency smack. If you can't step it up just a notch or two, don't come crying to me about smacking you thru the arch like dinsdale playing croquet.

After third base umpire Mike Winters ruled it a fair ball, the left side of the Cardinals' infield and left fielder John Rodriguez protested and that prompted an argument from La Russa. The umpires huddled and overruled the call -- replays showed the ball clearly foul -- and that brought Cubs manager Dusty Baker out. After circling the bases, Lee had to return to the plate and flied out.

check.......................mate, now shut the fuck up

The ball was obviously foul. Every single replay showed foul. If your 1983 Magnovox doesn't discern between the colors white and yellow you may have trouble seeing the ball cross in front of the foul pole.

Bullshit. It was a fair ball. I watched it disappear behind the foul pole during the slo-mo replay. Twice!

I don't care what a couple of Cards fans wishfully thought they saw thru red-tinted glasses.

I know what I saw.

Wags, they showed an angle that was impossible to deny. The ball was left of the foul pole and never came close.

Don't you think Dusty Baker would have truly lost his fucking mind if that had been even relatively close?

Ok, if an unbiased observer saw it differently, then I'll default to my primary point, without conceding the secondary. I still say it was a homerun...but I could be wrong.

MLB needs instant replay.

War Wagon wrote:primary

:swoon:

Rozy gets it. I think.

BTW- It was foul. Fuck Cubfan. DIE, DIE, DIE!!!

PrimeX wrote:I think.

vvnh

RACK WANDY

Wags, we don't need a discussion on the physical motion of a particular baseball to determine conclusively and without possibilty of parole, contradiction, retribution, institution, pollution, or cornnuts that Joe Morgan is a FUCKING BUFFOON.

He is the PRIMARY idiot in all of baseball broadcasting. Well, 'ceptin fer that sapsucker name o' McCarver.

That shit was foul.

Cardinalfan obviously saw things the way it would benefit them. If Pujols or Edmonds hit that ball we'd be hearing a different story. The ball dissapeared when it crossed the foul pole, and as Morgan was saying "see the ball never dissapears" in the replay, YES IT DID. Conclusion = HR.

As far as the argument about "well it ended up 3 feet foul", I don't suppose the trajectory or spin of the ball and the fact that it was the WINDY CITY had anything to do with that. :roll:

It was a HR, and Morgan is a tard.

off this shit troll ^^^^^^^^^^

Off this whole shit argument.

Adelpiero wrote:off this shit troll ^^^^^^^^^^

Sensitive subject area Adelp? It was ruled foul so what are you so bitter about? Don Denkinger? World Series sweep last year?

And even if the Tards win the Central by 20 games they won't win the World Series this year.

Jeff 2K5 wrote:The ball dissapeared when it crossed the foul pole

Either you are a moron or a troll.

TFKYOA.

As for Cubsfan, just stick your head in the sand and wait for next year. RedSox won the world series so I guess the biggest loser title goes to the Cubs now.

Jeff 2K5 wrote:The ball dissapeared when it crossed the foul pole, and as Morgan was saying "see the ball never dissapears" in the replay, YES IT DID. Conclusion = HR.

^^^Facts.

Some blind mofo's around here, apparently.

I kept waiting for Morgan to swallow his tongue, or at least say..."wait a minute, upon further review, that was a fair ball".

But nope, that bad call just got ignored.

Whatever, I still call bullshit.

Bizzarofelice wrote:

Jeff 2K5 wrote:The ball dissapeared when it crossed the foul pole

Either you are a moron or a troll.

Kill the messenger eh?

You can believe what you want, but I'll tell it like it is.

now we know whos shit troll it is!

I don't troll, dumbass. And IF I were to troll, it damn sure wouldn't be as a 'skins fan.

As a Cardinal fan, I saw the play, the replays that night, the replays on the news and the replays on spartscenter the next morning. Each time it was foul. Each time they showed it from behind home plate it was foul. Each time they showed it up close from the third base line it was foul.

I know someone from Kansas City might have their memory of a play distorted with time, so it would be best to agree with me and recognize my infinite wisdom.

When you put it that way, it's hard to argue.

Soft words well spoken turneth away anger...and that's why I'm a Bacefan.

Even so, we shall agree to disagree.

All I know is the ball dissapeared when it crossed the foul pole from the angle I saw.

Anyone find a video of it?

Yes Jeff, but sometimes you have to concede to the infinite wisdom, even if it says that black is white and up is down.

War Wagon wrote:Yes Jeff, but sometimes you have to concede to the infinite wisdom, even if it says that black is white and up is down.

I see. Carry on.